Logo Votation
=============

Candidates
----------

~~z~~
 http://dev.xonotic.org/projects/xonotic/wiki/Concept\_Art

Dokujisan (with some of morphed's on there too, like \#29)
 http://www.nullgaming.com/stuff/x/

Morphed
 http://deiz2.ath.cx/xonotic-mp4.png
 http://img232.imageshack.us/img232/949/xonoticlogo11.jpg
 http://img146.imageshack.us/img146/7523/xonoticlogo12.jpg
 http://img196.imageshack.us/img196/3679/xonoticlogo13.jpg (just slighty improved 12)
 http://www.morphed.planetnexuiz.com/xonotich264v3.mp4

MirceaKitsune
 http://dev.xonotic.org/attachments/download/17/logo\_idea\_5.jpg (blue)
 http://dev.xonotic.org/attachments/download/18/logo\_idea\_7.jpg (red)
 http://dev.xonotic.org/attachments/download/20/logo\_idea\_8.jpg (blue nodetail)
 http://dev.xonotic.org/attachments/download/21/logo\_idea\_9.jpg (red nodetail)
 http://dev.xonotic.org/attachments/download/23/logo\_idea\_10.jpg (blue on red nodetail)
 http://dev.xonotic.org/attachments/download/24/logo\_idea\_11.jpg (red on blue nodetail)

Deiz
 http://deiz2.ath.cx/firebird.png

Voting instructions
-------------------

Three votes each one suggested

Voting choices
--------------

mand1nga: Dokujisan's 16, 28, MirceaKitsune red

a grue:
1. MirceaKitsune's red nodetail
I don't like anything else right now.

C.Brutail
Dokujisan's 28 for main logo
Morphed's xonoticlogo8.jpg upper one for ingame items and banners

Dokujisan
1. \#28 for main logo (top of website, opening splash page in game)
2. \#16
3. Morphed's \#29 for ingame items... if he can adjust it to make it more fire-like (like the tail).
4. Deiz's firebird :~~)
SavageX
Dokujisan's 26 or 28 , 23
Ronan
1. \#24 or derivatives
2. Morphed's http://deiz2.ath.cx/xonotic-mp4.png
3. \#17
Merlijn:
1. Taoki \#11
2. Morphed \#11
3. Doku \#17
pavlvs:
1. Doku 28
2. Doku 9
3. Morphed logo11 with more tail
tZork:
doku 28, 16
morphs flamy one.
Spaceman
1. Morphed xonoticlogo11.jpg
2. Dokujisan \#6 or \#7
3.~~z- http://dev.xonotic.org/attachments/15/xonotic\_phoenix-1g.svg

Oblivion
1. Doku \#28
2. MirceaKitsune \#9 (red one without the X) - scratch that. Changing to the new \#11, but hopefully with a red aura for the flame feel.
3. Morphed \#11 (provided the wings are changed, as they look more like claws/spider legs)

DiaboliK
1. Doku \#28
2. Morphed 12
3. morphed 29

MirceaKitsune:
I like Dokujisan's logos and those using their exact design. From his list:
1. \#29 (and different color versions) - http://www.nullgaming.com/stuff/x/xonoticlogo8.jpg
2. \#9 - http://www.nullgaming.com/stuff/x/xonotic\_logo\_idea11.jpg
3. \#16 - http://www.nullgaming.com/stuff/x/xonotic\_logo\_idea18.jpg
(4. Morphed's video for intro, if its logo is changed to the logo decided after voting)

lda17h:
1. http://img196.imageshack.us/img196/3679/xonoticlogo13.jpg
2. http://www.nullgaming.com/stuff/x/ \#9
3. http://dev.xonotic.org/attachments/download/18/logo\_idea\_7.jpg

rabs
1. Doku \#28 http://www.nullgaming.com/stuff/x/xonotic\_logo\_idea28.jpg
2. ~~z~~ main picture at http://dev.xonotic.org/projects/xonotic/wiki/Concept\_Art
3. Doku \#7 http://www.nullgaming.com/stuff/x/xonotic\_logo\_idea9.jpg

RoKenn
1. Morphed \#11 http://img232.imageshack.us/img232/949/xonoticlogo11.jpg
2. Doku \#24 http://www.nullgaming.com/stuff/x/xonotic\_logo\_idea24.jpg
3. Doku \#25 http://www.nullgaming.com/stuff/x/xonotinstalled by defaultic\_logo\_idea25.jpg
(and Morphed's video as game intro)

Samual
\#1: Dokujisans \#27 or \#28 http://www.nullgaming.com/stuff/x/xonotic\_logo\_idea25.jpg (Also using the center piece as the icon for the game)
\#2: ~~z~~'s logo, although i'm not sure how well we can make it into an icon.
\#3: Morphed's main logo http://img196.imageshack.us/img196/3679/xonoticlogo13.jpg (I like this quite a bit, but I don't like how overpowering the red is in it.)

As for intro video, morphed's needs 2 things: \#1: The effects could be worked on and improved greatly.. It's (No offense) rather poor quality at the moment. Although it would be fine at first, I think our goal is for something smoother and more polished than that \#2: It needs to be 16:9 aspect ratio.

Rad\_Ished
1. Doku \#28

divVerent
1. Dokujisan \#14
2. Taoki logo\_idea\_8 or logo\_idea\_10 or logo\_idea\_11
3. Dokujisan \#28
(4. Morphed xonotic-mp4)

~~z~~'s logos: I like all the phoenixes, but none of the finished logos - the font simply does not work, I read it "xontic".
Dokujisan's logos: the ones with X in the logo are unacceptable, as it reads "xonxtic" then.
Morphed: the fire effect is just too much for a good logo - logos should be simple to remember and easy to "draw similarily"

Hew:
Doku \#28
Doku \#26
MirceaKitsune red nodetail

bones\_was\_here
1. Doku \#28
2. MirceaKitsune red nodetail

Xeno:
Dokujisan \#28
(sorry but it's the only one I really like, so the only one that I'me voting for)

esteel:
- Z's 1b
- MirceaKitsune's idea\_8
- Docu's 23
Also wanna not that the logos should have no special handling of the middle "O" excpet for size maybe.. with an different color then the rest of the name the O tends to not be noticed as a letter but just as goodie for the phoenix..